Healthy Red Velvet Cake with Vanilla Frosting

This is definitely an exciting cake to share.  As embarrassing as it is, it took me nine trials to make a successful all-natural, healthynutritionally balanced Red Velvet Cake.  I’ve done the research, I’ve done the measuring, I’ve done the thinking, and I’ve definitely done the taste testing (where do you think all those batches went?!).  Thank goodness every trial was healthy, otherwise my hips would be hanging off the seat as I type this…

Anyways, making a healthy (and tasty) Red Velvet Cake took a lot more work than I thought.  The batter has to be acidic, the cake has to be moist, it has to taste sweet sweet sweet, and lastly, it has to look red.  Duh.  But to meet my standards, the recipe also has to be good for you, which is quite the contrary to this classic Southern recipe.  Here are the ingredients I had to swap:

  • AP Flour, Cake Flour  >  Whole Grain Gluten-Free Flours
  • Oil, Butter, Shortening  >  Beet Puree, Coconut Oil
  • Artificial Food Coloring  >  Natural Food Coloring
  • Eggs, Egg Yolks  >  Egg Whites
  • Buttermilk  >  Unsweetened Almond Milk
  • Sugar  >  All-Natural Erythritol

That’s a lot of substituting to make, yes?  So, I guess we should start from the beginning:  Trial #1.

Take a deep breath…

Trial #1:

Healthy Red Velvet Cake

I based the recipe off my Citrus Pound Cake recipe, since that is the recipe my friends and family request me to make the most.  The texture was great, but had no flavor whatsoever.  The cake was red, but not burn-your-eyes-out red like the classic red velvet cakes.  The frosting was too thin and wasn’t very sweet.

Trial #2:
I improved some of the problems from Trial #1, but the cake tasted off.  I tried coloring it without food coloring by using beet puree but it turned more like a faded fuchsia.  There wasn’t enough cocoa and the cake was a little dry.

Trial #3:
I changed routes and decided to make Red Velvet Brownies rather than cake.  I based the recipe off my Lemony Peach Blondies, but it turned a Devil’s Food Cake color and tasted too much of chocolate to be a red velvet.

Trial #4:
I fixed some of the problems from Trial #3 but the brownies still had that Devil’s Food Cake color.  The brownies were extremely doughy, sticky and difficult to slice.  It had a less noticeable chocolate flavor, but now it had no flavor.

Trial #5:
This trial ended up being really doughy and sticky as well.  It was slightly cakey and had a great taste but the flavor was simply not that of a red velvet.  Unfortunately, it was an unappealing faded red-brown color.  Ugly, but tasty!

Trial #6:
This trial = DISASTER!  I doubled the recipe and baked the batter in cake pans rather than brownie pans.  The cake was soft, moist and delicious, yet a little on the dense side.  I tried using a different brand of food coloring but it turned the cake a hideous greyish-brown color.  While people liked the cake, no one really understood what the main flavor was.  I told them it was supposed to be a red velvet but ended up looking like chocolate.  Didn’t matter too much though, cake is cake.  And it’s healthy?  Okay, this cake is good cake!

Trial #7:
I quit it with the red and made this Orange Velvet Pumpkin Layer Cake.

Trial #8:

healthy red velvet cake

I did some more research on how to get a cake to turn red naturally.  It’s a science, not something I could guess on.  So when I sliced into this cake I thought I was going to see red.  Oh I saw red, just not in the freaking cake.  GAH!  I wanted to cry and throw my stand mixer out the window smush the cake with my hands.  I carved myself a slice and angrily shoved it in my face.  Oh.  My.  Gosh… it was delicious.  It was a bit dense, like the previous trial, but so damn good.

Trial #9:  (Finally, success!)
Before I even turned on the oven, I expected a baking failure that day.  I mean, I was let down 8 times already, my confidence in baking truncated with each failed trial… I expected less than post-worthy results that day.  To my surprise, though, things were looking up!  The batter was a bright fuchsia and turned more and more red as the cakes baked in the oven.  Good things do happen when you least expect them to.  I sliced the cake and my heart skipped a beat, I almost fainted.

FINALLY.  It was RED!  (Thank you baking gods)

I was so excited to take a bite that I ate a slice right off the cake stand.

This cake is absolutely delicious.  It’s sweet, it’s fluffy, it’s moist, it’s red.  Naturally red.  It’s nutritious, free of sugar, butter and all things artificial and manmade.  If you gave this to me when I was ten years old (you know, when I ate three Hershey bars a day and ate Pillsbury frosting out of the tub?), I would have eaten this without any complaints.  I would have eaten this with my hands (because who needs a fork?) in about 2 minutes flat.

Oh wait, that’s what I did as a twenty year old…

Anywaysss, this cake is magnificent.  Both a success and accomplishment that were a long time coming.  Nine trials long, but totally worth every hour spent researching (and eating).

Naughty or Nice Cookbook: The ULTIMATE Healthy Dessert Cookbook – Jessica Stier of Desserts with Benefits

Find the recipe in the Naughty or Nice Cookbook!

With 70 secretly healthy dessert recipes, full-color pages and photos for every recipe, you’ll soon discover what heaven feels like.  See this page for more information on the book, including the Table of Contents, some sneak peaks, and sample images.

Naughty or Nice Cookbook: The ULTIMATE Healthy Dessert Cookbook – Jessica Stier of Desserts with Benefits

Get your copy from Amazon here!

78 comments on “Healthy Red Velvet Cake with Vanilla Frosting

  1. YOU DID IT!!!!

    You finally came up with the perfect red velvet cake recipe. I’m almost jealous. It looks so amazing too! (So does trial #8… I say you should’ve posted that one too!)

    I think I’m gonna have to give this one a try… seriously, it just looks perfect in every way. I want a piece right now!

    Pinning! :)

    Oh, btw, congrats on the new look and name. Love it! Absolutely love it! :)

  2. OH. MY. GOSH. Ten tries, you’re a trooper. I would have given up. I need to show this to my baking friend. She has been trying to dye red velvet cake naturally for a while now. By the way, it looks just incredible.

  3. Wow!!! It looks wonderful!! I need an occasion to make this ^^
    Do you think I could puree canned beets if I’m lazy? Would that work, or are roasted beets necessary?

    • dessertswithbenefits

      I used canned beets in one of the trials and it didn’t give off as bright a red color as the freshly roasted beets, probably because the color is diluted in the water the beets are canned in… however, you can give it a try because the recipe provided is more likely to retain the red color because of its acidity. If you try it, let me know how it turns out! Fingers crossed :)

  4. Wow Jessica. Thats so much work you did and one perfect cake =-O.
    I love the color and Im sure it tastes as good as it looks!

  5. Your cake looks beautiful! You did a wonderful job making this one healthy with beet puree – I need to try this sometime :)

  6. Mmm, this looks so divine! The colour is so intense, it looks totally fab!

    Btw, do you make your nut butters with this: (I found it in the Desserts with Benefits Amazon page)? Would you recommend it for making nut butters?

    • dessertswithbenefits

      Yes, I make all my nut butters with that food processor. I love the small size and small price tag, but it takes a few minutes longer to turn the nut into a nut butter than a larger food processor. You have to scrape down the sides of the bowl more often, too, but it’s not a huge deal. If you are a nut butter freak, I would suggest a slightly larger processor, but if you use it mostly for small kitchen projects and the occasional nut butter, it’s perfect :)
      (Also, the type of nut makes a difference. Softer nuts like walnuts are super easy to butterize, but dryer nuts like hazelnuts take a bit longer)
      Hope I helped!

  7. Wow, your site looks amazing!! I love the new design and name change. This cake looks absolutely fabulous! Thanks for going through all those trials… 9, holy cow. I think I would have given up after the 3rd! I’m so glad you kept going. This will be the perfect cake for Valentines!

  8. Thank you so much for answering my questions :-) It sounds like that food processor would suit my food-processing needs and my small kitchen perfectly!

  9. This is awesome! I can’t wait to try this – I’m just recently trying to eat gluten-free to help manage my chronic headaches, but I love cake so much – Now I can have cake!

  10. It is amazing what you can do with these alternative ingredients. this cake looks so beautiful that I featured it on my Friday Five Valentine sweets addition over @ Feed Your Soul –

  11. Can you recommend a different sweetener, I don’t have erythritol. can I use granulated stevia?
    Also I will be using coconut oil instead of vege shortening for the frosting. Any recommendations for a sub for the powdered erythritol?
    Thanks, I LOVE YOUR SITE!!!!!

    • dessertswithbenefits

      You can use any dry sweetener to replace the erythritol, as long as it’s a 1:1 ratio replacement for sugar. Any powdered sweetener can replace the powdered erythritol. Good luck I hope you like the recipe!!

  12. I thought the beets would lend their color to the cake batter. So, did the color “rust” in the heat of baking? Is the added natural food coloring what made the difference in last attempt?
    can’t wait to make this for my nieces, thanks for all your effort & sharing 😀

    • dessertswithbenefits

      The color actually got better with baking, probably due to the batter’s acidity. The batter was bright fuschia and turned red. There was no discoloring from the baking pan (I got that in my previous trials, where the center was a little red but the outside just brown) which was awesome. I think the food coloring is what made this a red velvet… the beets alone are just hot pink… super hot pink lol.
      I hope you and your nieces LOVE the recipe!
      -Jess :)

  13. So, I made this today! I used canned beets and substituted coconut milk for the food coloring because I wasn’t particularly interested in the red color. I rather expected this to be somewhat of a dud because I didn’t really follow the recipe to a T, but it is SO AMAZINGLY GOOD. I couldn’t believe it, it tastes like a sugar-butter-flour cake, quite like the chocolate cake my mom used to make. THANK YOU, JESSICA! Your 9 trials have not been in vain! I can’t wait to eat this all up so I can make it again!!!!!

    • dessertswithbenefits

      Oh yayyy I’m so glad the cake turned out well for you! After 9 trials I think I’m too spent to make any more adjustments to the recipe, so I’m glad your venture turned out so great! Thanks for sharing your results :)

  14. Hi,

    This is a fantastic recipe, and great fun to make with the kids. Thanks so much for posting it.

    All the best, Alex

  15. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  16. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  17. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  18. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  19. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  20. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  21. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  22. Thanks for this awesome recipe! Making it for my son’s birthday this week. I was going to make the cake the day before and then frost it the following day. Should the cake be refrigerated when it’s unfrosted? What about when it’s frosted?


  23. Pingback: Red Velvet Pumpkin Cupcakes with Chocolate Pumpkin Cream Cheese Frosting | True Healthy Me

  24. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  25. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  26. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  27. this sounds great, can’t wait to make this cake, I am now on a glutin free trial, and love cake, so this should satisfiy my taste buds beautifully. Thank you very much for all your hard work and sharing. Can I sustitue the coconut milk with something else as I am alergic to coconut? cheers, Pauline :)

    • dessertswithbenefits

      Any other “milk” should substitute the coconut milk just fine. My favorite is almond milk. Soy milk, any other nut milk and (preferably organic) dairy milk should work just fine :)
      I hope you like the cake!!

  28. Hi jessica..
    Thank you for your recipe
    I was greatly helped by the recipes that you create.
    because I was conducting research for my thesis about making healthy red velvet..

    I’ve tried to make this cake with a few different ingredients.

    The recipe
    244g (1 cup) Roasted Beet Puree (see instructions) + 1 tbs Lemon Juice
    1/2 cup Unsweetened Almond Milk (i use Unsweetened Soya Milk

    183g (3/4 cup) Egg Whites
    96g (1/2 cup) Granulated Erythritol (i use low calorie sugar for cook/baking)
    14g (1 tbs) Grapeseed Oil
    2 tsp Stevia Extract (i didn’t use it)
    2 tsp Vanilla Extract
    1 tsp Butter Extract (i didn’t use it)
    120g (1 cup) Oat Flour (I use Modified cassava or Mocaf Flour)
    120g (3/4 cup) Brown Rice Flour
    32g (1/4 cup) Arrowroot Starch
    1 tsp Baking Powder
    1/2 tsp Salt
    15g (3 tbs) Regular Cocoa Powder (unsweetened)
    4 tbs Natural Red Food Coloring (I used Natures Flavors)
    1/2 tsp Baking Soda
    1 tbs White Vinegar (I use Apple Vinegar)

    How? 😀

    i want to ask you about this your recipe
    whether if it removes ingredients(stevia extract,butter extract) make effect on the cake?

    if yes, is there a substitute ingredient for it?

    FYI: in indonesia cake always made from margarine.. can i change the butter extract with this?

    Thank you for your helping.. i’m sorry for my english.. :)

  29. Pingback: Desserts With Benefits

  30. Hi! I had a few questions, so I tried the recipe last night and could still taste the beets and it did not rise as much as I had expected (might have been because I thought we were supposed to combine all wet ingredients together and all dry ingredients together so I didn’t make the vinegar/baking soda mixture as instructed :/). However, I plan on trying it again but had a few questions:
    1) The ingredients state 120g brown rice flour but only 3/4c is this accurate or is there a typo in the number of grams?
    2) if we decide to omit the red food coloring will we need to add anything to the batter or is it fine to just leave it out altogether? I don’t care too much about the color being so red.
    3) is the stevia extract a liquid or a powder?
    Thank you in advance! :)

    • Zahia-
      Oh no! I have no idea why you could taste the beets. The baking soda and vinegar mixture shouldn’t have changed the flavor of the cake too much, it’s more for the red color.
      1) I baked this cake by weight, I just provide the volumetric measurements as a guideline. According to the brown rice flour I use (Bob’s Red Mill), 1/4 cup = 40g… I used 120g so that should equal something around 3/4 cup.
      2) If you omit the red food coloring, simply increase the amount of almond milk by 1/4 cup.
      3) The stevia extract I use it liquid.
      Hope this helps!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This website may use cookies.